GET EDALJI

A CRIMINAL CASE ANALYSIS
By Rose H. Schmollek

It’s 1888. Mys­ter­i­ous events keep Great Wyr­ley, a vil­lage in Stafford­shire (West Mid­lands of Eng­land), in sus­pense. Threat­en­ing and anonym­ous let­ters, weird adverts in the loc­al news­pa­pers, and mutil­ated, killed anim­als bring fear and dread to the par­ish. The vicar’s son, George Ernest Thompson Edalji, is at the centre of these unusu­al activ­it­ies, which is reas­on enough for the Stafford­shire police to con­sider him a suspect.

But why should an edu­cated young man, a law­yer in Birm­ing­ham, do some­thing this crazy? Why should any­one ter­ror­ise a par­ish with anonym­ous let­ters, false announce­ments, and faked advert­ise­ments for decades?

In 1903, when George Edalji is sen­tenced to sev­en years of pen­al ser­vitude, many people, includ­ing celebrit­ies such as the author Sir Arthur Con­an Doyle, stand up for the con­vict. But is George Edalji only sus­pec­ted due to racist motives and xeno­pho­bia because his fath­er, the vicar Shapurji Edalji (a Parsee), once came from Bom­bay to England?

George Edalji’s own opin­ion in 1906:*

Nev­er­the­less, this story has been retold like this since 1907. We researched the crime case of George Edalji in col­lab­or­a­tion with forensic lin­guists, who did ana­lyses sug­gest­ing that Sir Arthur Con­an Doyle was mis­taken in his case assess­ment. We dis­covered answers to ques­tions and con­tra­dic­tions that have been delib­er­ately ignored until today.

*The video fea­tures Edalji’s 1906 pub­lished state­ment and is AI-gen­er­ated, based on a drawn por­trait of George Edalji by Mar­jola Mucollari.

BOOK